It looks like a trend

On the Trends list a push and a groundswell can look the same: posts are up, and the topic is climbing. The difference is in the timing.

Media Verdict console
  1. 01

    Ordinary interest

    People who care about a topic post at their own pace, so their posts scatter in time.

  2. 02

    A push

    Accounts acting together do the same thing within seconds of each other, and do it again, so their posts stand in columns.

  3. 03

    On the list

    When coordinated activity is found on a topic, the Trends list marks it “Looks organised”.

Four steps

The product runs the first three steps every five minutes for each trend, on the previous topic snapshot. An analyst reads the result and records it.

Media Verdict console
1 2 3 4
Illustration
  1. 1

    Notice

    A topic is trending. Coordination runs every five minutes for each trend, on the previous topic snapshot, whether or not anyone asked.

  2. 2

    Group

    Accounts that did the same thing inside a short window, the same repost, text, link, hashtag, hashtag sequence or media, are paired. Pairs that act together well beyond chance are kept, and groups of at least five accounts are found among them.

  3. 3

    Check each member

    For every member the reviewer sees five checks: an account created inside the group’s creation window, a profile picture found elsewhere, posting hours against stated location, posts outside the campaign, and how many of its replies stay inside the group. They are aids for the reviewer, never the decider.

  4. 4

    Record

    The finding is stored with its method, the windows, the cut-off and the thresholds, and the members and pairs can be exported so a rerun gives the same report. Attach it to a case to keep it with the rest of the team’s work.

What the finding looks like

An example finding for one topic. The accounts and the values are illustrative.

PartIn this example
GroupOne group of six accounts, Account A to Account F, holding at least one in twenty of the topic’s posts.
How they acted togetherThe same repost within 60 seconds, three times in ten minutes.
Measures above their markThree of the eleven: co-repost density, inter-arrival gaps and repeat offenders. A finding needs at least three.
LabelLikely coordinated, with its score. With fewer than three measures above their mark, the same score would read as a lead.
Member checksFor each of Account A to Account F, the five checks, filled in where the inputs exist and left empty where they do not.
MethodThe ways of acting together used, the window for each, the statistical cut-off, the thresholds and the configuration version.

When a campaign fades

A topic’s life runs through five phases: just started, picking up, at its peak, calming down and faded. The drawing shows the last four.

1. The band marks the time the topic was labelled likely coordinated.

2 to 5. Picking up, at its peak, calming down and faded. Calming down means falling for ten minutes, or below six tenths of its peak; faded means below one and a half times usual for 30 minutes.

One of the default rules tags a topic as a faded campaign when it enters calming down after a likely coordinated label. It is shipped switched off, and the policy owner switches it on. That moment is the red line in the drawing.

The accounts are not forgotten. A member found in groups in two or more earlier topics within 90 days counts as a repeat offender in later findings, and the Accounts screen lists repeat accounts across your cases. The daily report lists topics that peaked and faded inside its window, with both times.

Media Verdict console
1 2 3 4 5
Illustration

What not to conclude

Do not conclude who is behind it. A finding shows that Account A to Account F acted together, how and when. Who directs them is a question for your analysts.

Do not conclude that the accounts are automated. The method was built on campaigns run through ordinary, long-standing accounts posting templates on a schedule.

Do not conclude that what the accounts say is false. Coordination is about how posts arrive, not whether they are right.

Do not read a lead as a finding. A lead is a high score with fewer than three measures above their mark, or a score between the two lines with three or more.

Do not conclude that a topic with no finding was not organised. Only public posts are read; a campaign organised on WhatsApp or in private groups is seen only when it reaches public platforms.

The score becomes a probability only once calibrated on at least 50 topics labelled by two of your analysts who agree closely enough. Until then it is a score.

Bring a push your team suspected was organised, and walk through the four steps on it.

Request a demo